Bishop Robert McElroy delivers homily at vigil for Archbishop John Quinn

"John Quinn was unceasingly a man who combined continuity and transformation, and in that identity lay his greatness as a leader in the Church in the United States"

Retired San Francisco Archbishop John R. Quinn, left, is pictured in a 2004 photo in Saginaw, Mich. He died June 22 at age 88 in San Francisco. He headed the Northern California Archdiocese from 1977 until 1995. (CNS photo/Brett McLaughlin, Catholic Weekly)

Homily for the Vigil of Archbishop John Quinn
July 9, 2017
Bishop Robert W McElroy

For two generations of priests, religious, lay leaders and deacons in the archdiocese of San Francisco and across the United States, a retreat led by Archbishop John Quinn on the theme of discipleship and baptismal vocation would always end with the reading we have just heard from the twenty-first chapter of the Gospel of John. For in its three central movements, the Johanine account of the encounter of the risen Christ with the apostles by the seashore points to the essential relationship of Christian discipleship, the experience of the resurrection, and the meaning of Eucharist.

The first of these movements is the call of the disciples to a renewed missionary commitment to the person and the work of Jesus Christ. The return of Peter and the apostles to the act of fishing symbolizes the moment after the death of Jesus when the twelve felt abandoned by God and returned to their former way of life. The call of Jesus from the seashore, the grace of the miraculous catch, and the heartfelt act of Peter diving into the sea symbolize the recommitment of the disciples to a life of mission which is reconstituted by and centered in the grace of the resurrection.

The second movement of tonight’s gospel is the disciples’ gradual understanding of the resurrection experience itself. At first the figure on the shore appears to be a stranger, radically different from the man Jesus whom they had accompanied every day for almost three years.  But then they comprehend it is the Lord. The risen Jesus is both earthly and ethereal: He is translucent and yet eats with them. He prepares their meal. Raymond Brown points to these dual realities of continuity and transformation as the essential elements of Christ’s resurrection and of our own. In the fullness of the Kingdom our identities will survive, yet we will be radically altered. The experience on the seashore conveys to the disciples that both their own life in eternity and their new life of discipleship and ministry must be radically interwoven with the experiences of continuity and transformation.

Finally, the meal on the seashore points to the Eucharistic meal that embodies the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. And it does so precisely as an act of continuous thanksgiving.  Like the disciples on the road to Emmaus at the moment of the breaking of the bread, when Jesus instructs the apostles on the seashore “come and eat your breakfast,” they recognize clearly the presence of Jesus risen from the dead, Jesus who is their teacher, companion and friend. And in that recognition they are overwhelmed with gratitude to God.

In a very real way, these three themes of the Johanine encounter by the seashore  — the continuing call to discipleship and priesthood, the experience of continuity and transformation, and unceasing gratitude to God –  formed the life of John Raphael Quinn at its core and are the surest comfort and consolation for us at this hour of his death.

Priesthood, and the call to priesthood lay at the very center of John’s earthly mission. Every day he was profoundly grateful for the grace of his priesthood.  And as seminary professor, rector, bishop and spiritual director, Archbishop Quinn echoed the voice of the risen Jesus calling to the disciples from the shore. At times this voice was one of exhortation and inspiration encouraging men to explore a vocation to the priesthood. At other times, it was a voice of consolation and solace, reaching out to priests who had lost their way or were experiencing suffering which was overwhelming. He understood both the heroic striving and the great vulnerabilities of the human heart and spirit, and he understood how both that heroism and those vulnerabilities could be magnified in the priestly life. When he came to San Francisco, the archbishop told the gathered priests: “everyone in this diocese has a pastor except you. It is my hope that in some real measure I can be pastor to you”.  And over the following forty years, he became such a pastor, mentor, spiritual advisor and friend to so many of us who had been his priests and to a multitude of bishops across the country.

Continuity and transformation – the contours of the resurrection we await in the next world and the contours of all discipleship which is lived faithfully and effectively on earth. Two days before he was stricken in Rome, I had a long conversation with Archbishop Quinn. It was a poignant moment for the archbishop: participating in the consistory for his close friend Cardinal Cupich, speaking with the Holy Father with whom he shared so many commitments regarding the life of the Church and the world, returning to the North American College which had played such a pivotal role in his formation. That morning he had visited the room which he occupied as a young seminarian more than sixty years before. The archbishop told me that this trip had been a time of recapitulation for him, embracing both the earliest foundations of his life and priesthood and the elements of growth and evolution which had emerged in his priestly life in a manner which he could never have dreamed of on the day of his ordination.

John Quinn was unceasingly a man who combined continuity and transformation, and in that identity lay his greatness as a leader in the church in the United States.  

It was this dual commitment which led him to find in the death and funeral of Oscar Romero a shattering call to prophetic leadership in pursuit of justice for the poor and the oppressed in Central America and the United States. It was John’s  ability to grow and to risk which led him to challenge the morality of nuclear deterrence in the 1980’s and to begin the first major diocesan outreach to victims of AIDS when fear and prejudice against this terrible scourge were at their height. It was the ability to grow and change in deepest fidelity to the gospel and the tradition of the Church which led Archbishop Quinn to find in his role as pontifical delegate for religious life both an opportunity to create new pathways for collaboration between bishops and women religious, and a new birth in his own life of effective mutual relationships with women. Finally, it was in his comprehension of both continuity and doctrinal development in the life of the Second Vatican Council and the writings of Cardinal Newman that John Quinn found the inspiration for his witness to synodality in church structures, his call for an expansion of the role of the laity in church governance, and the need for a rearticulation of Catholic teaching on responsible parenthood.

Continuity and change. It is the theme of our risen life in the Lord. It is the theme of any life of discipleship which never ceases to listen attentively to the voice of the glorified Lord calling to us from the seashore. It was a theme which animated and formed the discipleship of John Quinn every day that he lived on this earth.

The final great moment of the encounter of the disciples with the risen Christ at the seashore is the Eucharistic moment. It symbolizes the glory which John now enjoys in the kingdom of God. It symbolizes the unity of the Church rooted in baptism which John Quinn always considered the most important grace that he had received in the whole of his life. It symbolizes the spirit of profound gratitude to God which continually characterized John’s appreciation for the gift of his family, his vocation, his education, his friendships, and yes even these past five months of illness which were for him a genuine opportunity to bind himself more faithfully to the suffering Jesus Christ who had died on his behalf.

It had been apparent for most of those past five months that Jesus was likely preparing the heavenly meal for Archbishop John Quinn, even to those of us who were desperately hoping that the Lord would bid John once more to take up his nets and launch back onto the sea in service to the Church. Now John Quinn is embraced by his Lord and Savior. The Lord bids him “come and eat your breakfast”. And John knows that he is truly home.

From website of Diocese of San Diego.


  1. Joan of El Cajon says:

    Here’s a different take on Quinn’s priesthood, written by the late, great Paul Likoudis for The Wanderer in 2013:

    When Pope John Paul II convoked the 1980 synod, theological dissent, especially against the Church’s teaching on marriage and procreation, was raging. The dissenters’ position was given at the synod by the Archbishop John Quinn of San Francisco, who asked the synod fathers to reexamine Pope Paul VI’s Humanae Vitae since the overwhelming majority of U.S. Catholics had rejected it.
    Quinn’s intervention was praised by leading U.S. dissidents, such as Fr. Charles Curran, who called it “a huge step forward” and Jesuit Fr. Richard McCormick, who called it a “realistic” appraisal of the situation in the U.S. Church. Fr. William…

    • Blessedly, I did not listen to priests who approved the Birth Control Pill, or I would have been dead around twenty-seven years ago since my cancer was susceptible to the estrogen in it. Instead I listened to the older priest at my local parish who told me not to take it. He did send me to one of the conferences in San Francisco, but God guided me in the right direction through Our Lady’s intercession ( wearing of Miraculous Medal).

  2. I’m curious who the prelate in the center of the photo is. Also, why was Abp. Quinn in Saginaw? The caption told us he was in Saginaw but not why. I think the caption is incomplete in these respects.

    • Old Nuncio I think. Probably part of a delegation to install a new Bishop there.

    • anonymous says:

      The photo is from when Archbp. John R. Quinn was in Saginaw, MI for the funeral following the death of his good friend, the very liberal Bp. Kenneth E Untener, who was deceased Mar. 27, 2004. Quinn actually gave the homily according to contemporary obituaries describing the funeral:

      The other prelate dressed in red “looks like” then-Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, who was not US nuncio at the time, but was official papal representative around the world. He also used to appear to scowl at public events. It is definitely not Card. Adam Maida, who was then-Card-Archbp of Detroit, nor retired Card-Archbp. Edmund Szoka.

    • Charles Teachout says:

      The year 2004 was the year of the installation of the new Bishop of Saginaw, following the passing of Bishop Kenneth Untener. Bp. Quinn was a major supporter of Bp. Untener in his lifetime. Kenneth Untener was the Rector of St. John’s Provincial Seminary in Plymouth, MI. in the ’70s up to the breaking of a nationally publicized scandal in 1980 regarding the showing of pornographic movies to seminarians. A detailed account of the goings on of a “gay” seminarian subculture has been recounted in “Good Bye, Good Men” by former seminarian Michael S. Rose. Fr. Untener was brought to Rome, where he was successfully defended by several friends in the U.S. Hierarchy, most notably by Cardinal John Dearden, founder of the “Call to Action…

    • Charles Teachout says:

      Bp. Untener was advocated by the Head of the Michigan Catholic Conference Cardinal John Dearden at the time of Fr. Untener’s expulsion as Rector of the Regional Seminary of St. John’s in Plymouth. He argued strenuously on behalf of Untener and was successful in having Fr. Untener installed as the Bishop of Saginaw, MI in 1981.

  3. What is the expression about “Birds of a feather……?”

  4. I don’t care about anything McElroy has to say. As far as I’m concerned, he’s lumped in with persona non grata such as Fr. James Martin, Cardinal Cupich and Michael Sean Winters.

  5. Thanks for clarification. This certainly adds context to the photo.

COMMENTS POLICY: Comments are limited to 750 characters and will be truncated at 750. Comments should not contain offensive or libelous language. Please strive to be civil. All comments are subject to approval by our moderator and to editing as the moderator deems appropriate. Inclusion of your email address is optional.

Speak Your Mind

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

COMMENTS POLICY: Comments are limited to 750 characters and will be truncated at 750. Comments should not contain offensive or libelous language. Please strive to be civil. All comments are subject to approval by our moderator and to editing as the moderator deems appropriate. Inclusion of your email address is optional.